Best Super Bowl 59 Prop Bets: Unique Wagers to Consider
We all know that the Super Bowl isn’t just a football game anymore—it’s more like a national holiday for finger foods and betting on things that have absolutely nothing to do with football. And that’s why we’re here.
Yes, we’re talking about the fun (and kinda weird) prop bets (short for “proposition bets” for those who don’t know) that turn the Big Game into 5-hours of emotional chaos and your non-football friends asking, “Wait, can I actually bet on that?” You bet you can! It doesn’t matter if you’re in it for the sport or the spectacle—prop bets are your pass to caring about everything that’s happening, from the coin toss to whether the halftime show’s pyro will accidentally singe a celebrity’s eyebrows.
You don’t even have to fake being a football fan with prop bets, which is why we are gonna go over some of the most fun and slightly plausible (or totally implausible) ones for Super Bowl 59, so you can join in on the fun.
What Are Prop Bets?
Let’s kick it off with the basics—because no one wants to be that person who yells, “WHAT’S A PROP BET?!” when they have a mouthful of seven-layer dip. And no one wants to see that, either.
Prop bets are just the rebellious little siblings of traditional betting. Instead of wagering on who will win the game, you’re betting on literally anything else; the possibilities are endless.
- Will Patrick Mahomes shed a few tears during the MVP speech?
- Will we get a lunatic streaker who storms the field and gets tackled by security?
- Will the kicker’s shoelace snap mid-field goal?
- Will Travis Kelce propose to his more famous GF, Taylor Swift, during the trophy ceremony if the Chiefs achieve the three-peat?
You can see why prop bets are so popular and have gained a ton of momentum over the years—they are the ultimate equalizer. Your 14-year-old nephew can out-bet you by guessing the color of the winning coach’s Gatorade bath. And they turn almost every commercial break into a cliffhanger. They’re just really fun!
Types of Prop Bets
There are two main categories of prop bets, or flavors, for those of you who are only in it for the snacks: game-related and non-game-related.
- Game-related: These are mostly for the football purists—they’re bets on player or team performances. Stats, scores, and “will someone yeet a football into the stands?”
- Non-game-related: These have nothing to do with the game on the TV—they’re strictly entertainment and novelty bets and appeal more to the people who just came for the wings and nachos. National anthem drama, halftime show conspiracy theories, and whether a commercial will make you cry harder than that ASPCA ad.
Top Game-Related Prop Bets for Super Bowl 59
There are tons of prop bets in the works for Super Bowl 59, so let’s get into the top game-related ones for the Eagles vs. Chiefs showdown!
1- Player Performance Bets
These are for individual players, like will Patrick Mahomes throw for over 300 yards or spend the second half running for his life? This is where research comes into play—for player performance bets, check their track record: do they crumble under pressure, or are they basically robots that are programmed to ruin bettors’ lives (yes, we are talking about you, Mahomes)?
The following are some examples of individual player performance bets:
- Will the MVP throw for over/under 2.5 touchdowns?
- First fumble
- Which running back rushes for the first TD?
- Total receptions by a rookie wide receiver: Over/under 5.5?
- Total passing yards for Patrick Mahomes or rushing yards for Saquon Barkley, etc.
Insight
All past Super Bowl trends can give you really valuable insights for your prop bets. The following are the most notable patterns:
- Team Scoring Last Wins: In the past 15 Super Bowls, the team that scored last has won the game, a trend that suggests that betting on the team to score last could be a good one.
- Early Game Scoring: Seven of the last eight Super Bowls did not feature a score within the first six minutes of play, which shows us that early-game defenses are usually strong, and that makes bets on a scoreless first six minutes worth a second look.
- Length of Longest Touchdown: The average longest touchdown in recent Super Bowls has been 48 yards. Bets on the longest touchdown being under 48 yards have been really successful in six of the last seven games.
- First Quarter Scoring: In four of the last seven Super Bowls, the first quarter ended with a 0-0 score, which could influence bets on first-quarter scoring outcomes.
2- Team Milestones
- Will the first score be a touchdown or a field goal?
- Which team commits the first turnover?
- Will there be a defensive or special teams TD?
- Which team will score first?
- Will the game go into overtime?
Strategy:Here’s where you need to do some homework and review team stats and strategies from the playoffs—it’s worth it! Look at things like how often a team scores on their first drive and if they have a tendency to commit turnovers under pressure. Knowing their defensive capabilities and special teams’ performance will also help you to make better and more educated bets!
3- Unique Plays
- Successful 2-Point Conversion: Will a team attempt and succeed in a 2-point conversion? Teams often go for two in critical moments, and knowing their success rate can give you an edge.
- Game Going into Overtime: As we mentioned earlier, betting on whether or not the game will go into OT can be a valuable bet. Considering the competitiveness of the Chiefs and the Eagles? This is a super compelling wager.
Most Exciting Non-Game-Related Prop Bets
If football is not your thing, you can bet on the circus that comes with it!
National Anthem
You can bet on the length of the National Anthem! It’s usually an over/under of 2 minutes and 15 seconds. Will the singer forget the words? Will they hit that super high note like Mariah Carey or crack like a middle school choir soloist?
Betting on how long the national anthem will last is a Super Bowl staple. Below are some past performances and their lengths:
- Alicia Keys (Super Bowl XLVII): Holds the record for the longest rendition at 2 minutes and 36 seconds.
- Neil Diamond (Super Bowl XXI): The Cantor’s son delivered the shortest performance—it lasted only 1 minute and 2 seconds.
- Recent Trends: In the past decade, the average anthem length has been around 1 minute and 55 seconds.
Halftime Show
The halftime show prop bets are the most fun. We get Kendrick Lamar this year, and people are betting on whether or not he’ll perform “HUMBLE.” You can bet on any special guest appearances, and if Kendrick doesn’t do his biggest hits, will he force his latest album, which dragged Drake to the underworld, on us (we’re joking; the album is good; we are just hoping for “HUMBLE” or that he brings our Rihanna for “LOYALTY”).
- First Song Performed: Bettors usually try to predict the opening number. Like we said, with Kendrick Lamar headlining this year, “HUMBLE” is a popular bet.
- Total Number of Songs: The number of songs performed can vary, and shows have featured 11 or more songs, so there are prop bets on whether the count will be over or under a set number.
- Guest Appearances: Surprise guests have always been a big thing. This year, there’s a lot of speculation about artists like Future or SZA joining Kendrick Lamar on stage.
- Wardrobe Choices: Bets are placed on performers’ outfits, like if Kendrick Lamar wears a hoodie during his first song.
- Setlist Order: Predicting the sequence of songs—fans try to guess which hits will make the cut and in what order.
Commercial Bets
The Super Bowl commercials are legendary, and betting on them is now a really fun tradition. The following are some of the most popular commercial prop bets:
- Brand Battles: Which company’s ad will air first—Pepsi or Coca-Cola?
- Celebrity Cameos: Will a major star (and which one) make a surprise appearance in a commercial that airs?
- Ad Count: Which brand will have the most commercials during the game (and will it be all crypto ads like last year)?
- First Commercial to Air: Bettors usually wager on which brand’s commercial will be the first to air after the kickoff. Matchups like Budweiser vs. Bud Light or Cheetos vs. Heinz have been featured in past betting lines.
- Total Number of Commercials: Another common bet is on the total number of commercials aired during the game, with lines typically set around 96.
- Specific Brand Appearances: Bets are placed on whether specific brands, like Bud Light or Michelob Ultra, will air a commercial and which will pop up first.
Trends from Previous Years
- High-Profile Advertisers: Companies like Budweiser, PepsiCo, and FanDuel have been mainstays during Super Bowl commercial breaks. In recent years, Budweiser and PepsiCo have had a 98% or higher probability of airing ads during the game.
- Emergence of New Advertisers: Traditional brands always dominate, but there’s anticipation around new entrants. In past Super Bowls, companies like Progressive had a lower likelihood (around 5%) of airing commercials, which means there’s room for a few surprises.
- Animal Features: Animals, especially dogs, are a recurring theme in Super Bowl ads. Prop bets usually include the number of commercials that feature pups, with lines set around 6.5 in recent years.
Strategies for Betting on Prop Bets
Look, we may be betting experts, but we are not financial advisors—we’re just people who may have cried a little bit over losing a “Gatorade color” bet or two. That being said, there are some solid strategies for betting on prop bets!
Research and Trends
- Player and Team Performance: Analyze the statistics from the regular season and playoffs to try to spot any patterns. If a quarterback consistently throws for over 250 yards, betting on the “over” for their passing yards could be a solid wager.
- Injuries and Weather Conditions: Stay updated on all injury reports and weather forecasts, as these factors can and do influence game dynamics. A star player’s absence or adverse weather? That can affect scoring and player performances.
Entertainment Bets
- Information Leaks and Historical Data: As for novelty bets, like the length of the national anthem or halftime show deets, research all past performances and monitor credible leaks or news. Historical data can give you a benchmark, and reputable sources can offer solid insights into this year’s specifics.
Manage Your Bankroll
- Set a Budget: Pick a specific amount you’re willing to risk on prop bets, and don’t go over it! Managing your bankroll with discipline will prevent overspending and means that betting stays what it’s supposed to be, and that’s a fun activity.
- Diversify Your Bets: Instead of placing all your eggs in one basket, aka your funds, on a single prop bet, spread your wagers across multiple wagers. You’ll increase the chances of a positive return and mitigate possible losses.
Why Prop Bets Make Super Bowl 59 More Fun
Prop bets make the Super Bowl more fun for everyone—even those who don’t like football. You can bet on so many outcomes that don’t take pigskin knowledge, like the coin toss outcome, the length of the national anthem, or the color of the Gatorade that will be poured on the winning coach. They are all simple and fun so that everyone can participate!
Community Engagement
At Super Bowl parties, prop bets are indeed excellent conversation starters. Debating over which song the halftime performer will start with or guessing the number of commercials that feature man’s best friend will kick off really fun discussions. Common predictions and friendly wagers bring people together, and that makes the whole thing more interactive and enjoyable for everyone who’s there!
Memorable Prop Bet Moments
#OnThisDay six years ago, the Philadelphia Eagles beat the New England Patriots at Super Bowl LII🏆
Nick Foles dropped one of the most iconic plays in Super Bowl history: The Philly Special🔥#FlyEaglesFly pic.twitter.com/NSUJ4sdI2H
— Philly Iggles (@PhillyIggles_) February 4, 2024
In honor of Super Bowl prop bets, below are some of the most talked-about wagers from past games!
- Taylor Swift’s Game Appearances (2023-24 Seasons): When Taylor Swift started dating Kansas City Chiefs’ Travis Kelce in September 2023, her appearances at games caused a surge in “Swift-themed” prop bets. Bettors wagered on all kinds of outcomes, like the number of times Swift would be shown during broadcasts or if any of her songs would be referenced.
- Dave Portnoy’s Million-Dollar Bet (2025): Barstool Sports founder Dave Portnoy placed a $1 million bet on the Buffalo Bills to win the Super Bowl. The Chiefs defeated the Bills 32-29 in the AFC Championship game, so oopsies for Portnoy! Chiefs linebacker Drue Tranquill later taunted Portnoy on social media, which only added to the bet’s notoriety.
- “Philly Special” Trick Play (Super Bowl LII): Bettors had the option to wager on if a trick play would result in a touchdown. The Philadelphia Eagles executed the “Philly Special,” a trick play where quarterback Nick Foles caught a touchdown pass, and this made this prop bet a winner for those who anticipated it.
- Missed Extra Point (Super Bowl LI): With extra points being almost automatic, betting on a missed attempt can give you long odds. In Super Bowl LI, Stephen Gostkowski of the New England Patriots missed an extra point, and it turned this uncommon prop bet into a winning ticket for those who made it.
Conclusion: We’re All Outta of Wings
The bottom line is that prop bets turn the Super Bowl into a kind of choose-your-own-adventure game, and we love that. And so do the non-football fans who want to get in on the action but don’t want to research player and game stats!
Like we said, we are all out of the good snacks, so there’s nothing left to do but recap why prop bets add so much fun to the Super Bowl:
- Prop bets turn the Super Bowl into a choose-your-own-adventure game and are fun for everyone—even those who know nothing about football.
- Game-related = stats, scores.
- Non-game-related = anthems, commercials, half-time show drama, celeb guests, anything about Taylor Swift, and the iconic Gatorade shower’s color.
- Bet smart, laugh a lot, and don’t forget that it’s about the excitement—not the possible payout.
Grab your friends, pick your wagers, and let the chaos begin. And we want to hear your wildest prop bet predictions in the comments—we’re all ears!
Always gamble responsibly and within your means! Unless it’s a bet that Kendrick will bring out Drake for the halftime show—you can put all of your money on that NOT happening. Jk, jk, don’t do that!
